BestReviews is reader-supported and may earn an affiliate commission. Details
Jennifer has a decade-plus of experience testing the best products on the market, leading her neighbors to ask if she ever stops vacuuming.
With 35 pieces that provide more options to make numerous faces than a typical Potato Head, this kit tops our list for the best value Playskool has to offer of the classic toy.
With 35 pieces that provide more options to make numerous faces than a typical Potato Head, this kit tops our list for the best value Playskool has to offer of the classic toy.
Not only do you get Mr. Potato Head with this kit, but numerous pieces to make lots of funny faces. Comes with a storage case.
A few complaints of pieces that were difficult to put into the designated holes. The latch on the case could be sturdier.
This Potato Head has the star power kids will love – the one to get for fans of Toy Story 3.
This Potato Head has the star power kids will love – the one to get for fans of Toy Story 3.
A classic yet revamped Mr. Potato Head with pieces that create the look from the popular Disney movie Toy Story 4.
Lacking the eyebrows the character has in the movie.
This Potato Head toy is truly versatile, and offers kids the opportunity to create fun faces on 4 different characters.
This Potato Head toy is truly versatile, and offers kids the opportunity to create fun faces on 4 different characters.
Kids can create an entire Potato Head family with this kit that includes 2 standard and 2 small potato heads and accessories to make Mr. and Mrs. plus their pets. Comes with a storage case.
Priciest choice on our list, but you get a lot of pieces for your money. Reports of pieces that either won't fit or fall out of the potato holes.
Nothing fancy and no extra bells and whistles – but if you are looking for the classic Mr. Potato Head that kids have loved for generations, this is it.
Nothing fancy and no extra bells and whistles – but if you are looking for the classic Mr. Potato Head that kids have loved for generations, this is it.
The original Mr. Potato head with features that include a hat, mustache, shoes, and more – 13 pieces total.
Basic. Some consumers gripe about ill-fitting pieces, a common issue with the toy.
The female version of the classic toy – just like you may remember from your childhood.
The female version of the classic toy – just like you may remember from your childhood.
Mrs. Potato Head with pieces that include a purse, hairdo, shoes, and more – 12 pieces total. Earns praise for being "cute."
Pieces have been known to fit loosely, or fall out of the holes altogether. Some pieces are difficult to put into the holes.
We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.
The classic Potato Head toy has seen many changes over the years, and it’s still going strong.
Hasbro, the creator and manufacturer of Potato Head toys, announced recently that it's dropping the "Mr." from the brand name to be more gender-inclusive. Even so, the Mr. and Mrs. characters remain under the new brand name.
You may find yourself taking a trip down memory lane as you peruse the different Potato Head choices. But alongside the classic potato doll, you’ll find some new and exciting Potato Head products as well.
At BestReviews, we aim to help our readers find what they need. We do extensive product research, then present the facts in a thorough, easy-to-digest format.
Read on for our full guide to Potato Heads. Then, when you're ready to make a purchase, take a look at the five we’ve plucked out of the potato patch.
Potato Head is essentially a plastic potato with holes in which you can stick various included body parts.
Each Potato Head toy comes with a range of limbs, facial features, and more. These pieces can be arranged in either regular or abstract ways to create funny faces.
What you might not know is that, when the Potato Head toys were first released by Hasbro in the 1950s, they were simply a set of body parts. Buyers were expected to use a real potato that they provided themselves.
It wasn't until the 1960s that the Potato Head toys got their own plastic body.
Mr. Potato Head might be the original, but you'll find more Potato Heads out there. Below are the main members of the Potato Head family.
Mr. Potato Head is the original Potato Head toy, and he comes with a range of typically male accessories, such as a bowler hat and a moustache.
Since his accessories are fully interchangeable, they can be switched with those from any other Mr. Potato Head of the same size.
A basic Mr. Potato Head toy costs between $10 and $15, depending on the retailer.
While her body is roughly the same as that of Mr. Potato Head, she comes with a different set of accessories, including a purse and ears with earrings.
You can use Mrs. Potato Head accessories on Mr. Potato Head, and vice versa.
A standard Mrs. Potato Head toy costs between $10 and $15.
Special-edition Potato Heads are licensed to feature a range of characters from movies and TV shows in Potato Head form.
Popular options include Star Wars Potato Heads and Marvel Potato Heads.
These toys can cost between $10 and $25, depending on the type and the franchise.
Poptaters are produced by PPW Toys under license from Hasbro and feature a wide range of pop culture characters, from Groot to Jason Vorhees.
While they can be played with by children, Poptaters are predominately marketed as collector's items – and some are thematically unsuitable for younger people.
Though accessories are interchangeable, you can only switch them between other Potato Heads from the Poptater line due to their size.
Poptater figures tend to cost between $15 and $25.
A standard Mr. Potato Head toy comes with eyes, a nose, a mouth with teeth, a hat, a mustache, a tongue, a pair of glasses, two arms/hands, two ears, and one pair of legs with shoes.
A standard Mrs. Potato Head toy comes with eyes with eyelashes, a nose, a mouth, a purse, hair, a tongue, two arms/hands, two ears with earrings, and one pair of legs with shoes. Special-edition and Poptater toys come with various accessories depending on the model.
If you want some extra accessories for your Potato Heads, it's possible to buy packs of accessories that fit all standard dolls.
Different Potato Head toys come in different sizes. A standard Mr. or Mrs. Potato Head measures close to eight inches tall, whereas Poptaters are closer to six inches tall. You can also find some mini Potato Head figures that are just a couple of inches tall. As a rule, larger Potato Heads are easier to use for small children to use, since they might not possess the fine motor skills necessary to change the pieces on smaller models.
If you're buying a Potato Head doll for a child to play with, collectability probably isn’t important. After all, most kids want to play with their toys, not keep them in a box. But if you’re explicitly looking for collectible Potato Head dolls, consider purchasing special-edition and movie-themed versions. These are generally only available for a limited time.
Think about the interests of the recipient. Buying for someone who's Star Wars-obsessed? Consider a Darth Vader or Luke Skywalker Potato Head.
Decide whether you want some additional accessories. If your child is completely enamored by their Potato Head, some extra facial features and other accessories might just make her year.
Make sure any existing pieces are compatible with your new doll. If you're planning to add another Potato Head to an existing collection, make sure the one you choose has accessories compatible with the models you already own to avoid disappointment.
Consider how easy it is to carry around. Some Potato Heads come with a carrying case so your little one can more easily take it with him room to room, on playdates, and so on.
Look for interchangeable sets. Some mini Potato Head sets feature four small Potato Heads with interchangeable pieces instead of a single large one. These sets are usually themed. Marvel and Sesame Street are two popular examples.
Check if parts are easily replaceable. It's possible to buy accessory packs that contain extra body parts to increase the fun (or to replace parts that have gone missing).
A. Most Potato Heads are recommended for children of either age two and up or age three and up, depending on the model. This can vary, however, so always check the specs of the product you've chosen before purchasing. While there's no maximum age limit for Potato Heads, they're generally geared toward kids of preschool age.
A. You can find a wide range of special-edition Potato Heads, though some are available for limited periods, so the current availability may vary. Star Wars-themed Potato Heads are very popular, with characters such as "Luke Fry Walker," "Darth Tater," and "Mashter Yoda.” Characters from the Marvel universe, such as "Tony Starch" and "Spider Spud," are also well-loved. Past special editions have included characters from Star Trek, Doctor Who, and more.
A. Children as young as two or three can enjoy playing with Potato Head. Since playing with these toys simply involves poking body parts and accessories into the relevant holes, it really only requires basic fine-motor skills and hand-eye coordination. What's more, playing with Potato Head toys are a fun way to improve both of these functions.
Get emails you’ll love.
Learn about the products you’re wondering if you should buy and get advice on using your latest purchases.